We are cutting our carbon emissions by 5 tonnes.

On Sunday we are moving a ten minute walk (instead of a 45 minute commute) from where we both work – with two grocery stores between home and the office. And we’re switching to Good Energy.

What I like about them, despite the extra cost, is that I can be absolutely sure none of the profits from my “green tariff” will be used to build more coal, natural gas or nuclear plants. This is not the case with green tariffs from conventional suppliers. They promise you “100% green” energy, but while I was browsing suppliers yesterday, I discovered what that promise actually means. In almost every case, they buy from renewable energy sources (wholesale) the same amount of energy you pay for (retail). That’s it. And the profits are theirs to use (or pocket) as they see fit. Scottish Power pretends to offer a “100% green” tariff because they have a couple of dams up in Scotland. But dams aren’t all that green, besides which, the fuel mix for Scottish Power is 55% coal, 37% natural gas and only 6.8% “renewable” – which I assume refers to their dams – built between 1930 and 1936.

Of course those dams haven’t been sitting there for 80 years waiting for me to be willing to pay extra for “100% green” electricity. They were already in use and operating to capacity.  There’s no other way to do it with dams – if you don’t let the water out within a very particular range you will overflow or drain the reservoir.

And speaking of Scottish Power’s greed *cough* I mean green credentials, I wonder how it’s going with their subsidiary Pacificorp, in the US…

When PacifiCorp’s 50-year license to operate its six Klamath dams expired in 2002, stakeholders, along with local, state and federal agencies, assembled to participate in the processing of a new license application. The dams play a fundamental role in the decline of Klamath salmon by blocking more than 300 miles of historic spawning habitat and degrading water quality. Since the dams are poor power producers, offer no flood control and create reservoirs full of toxic blue-green algae each summer, there is strong local support for removing them.

At the same time that the Klamath dams’ license expired, PacifiCorp slammed irrigators with a sharp rate increase which for some families will result in a 1,200 percent increase in power bills. All of a sudden, farmers, fishermen, tribes and conservation groups began discussing how we could work together to have all of our needs addressed. Because our particular need is rather big – the removal of four dams, resulting in the largest river restoration project in America’s history – we are willing to work with farmers to address their needs at the same time

For its part, PacifiCorp remains defiant. The company seems more interested in gouging its own ratepayers than in making a responsible and sound business decision. That is to say that instead of working to ensure ratepayers get the cheapest out – dam removal – the utility would rather stick them with the excessive cost of bringing these outdated dams into compliance with modern environmental laws. Even installing ladders would do little to aid salmon recovery, because the degradation of water quality caused by the dams would remain. However, with at least a year left in the relicensing process, there’s still time for PacifiCorp to act responsibly and stop exploiting Native Americans, farmers and its own customers.

With Scottish Power, the “100% green” tariff appears to be nothing more than a cynical PR exercise.  All you get out of it is an opportunity to feel a bit better about your carbon emissions, while your hard earned money is siphoned off into new coal and nuclear plants, and to lengthy and expensive battles to avoid even the most basic environmental regulation.

Not so with Good Energy. They don’t deal in non-renewable energy at all. Yes, they are still shamelessly capitalizing on my consumer guilt, but the “green” they are selling is (apparently) real, not empty propaganda.

Anyway, I may not be blogging much due to packing and such, but when I return I will be in a much better moral position to shake my fist about environmental issues.


Tags: , , , ,

3 Responses to “We are cutting our carbon emissions by 5 tonnes.”

  1. cabraham Says:

    Good comments on capitalist greed in the new ‘environment’ market. While the opportunity for better living through energy efficiency is commendable, it really stinks for middle-to-lower class that can not afford the extra expense. In order to survive, they have to risk choosing the present and not accept the reality of the future. Of course, money is not the only issue preventing consumers from choosing green. Not enough companies take the time to break down the facts and show how an investment in green will benefit their household, the economy, and the environment.

    I work on behalf of Sharp, who is a company about change their act for a better future. While they do produce products that will one create waste, they have taken the measures to rethink how to efficient manufacture products for consumers and made the products into alternative energy sources. More information here: http://sharpgreen.smnr.us/ and let me know if you have any questions.

  2. Paul Says:

    Hope your move is going smoothly!

  3. apophaticattic Says:

    As smoothly as can be expected, I suppose, although we won’t have the internet set up for a while yet. Wampus left it a bit late so now we’re living in the stone age – no TV, no internet, no phone. I have swapped over every light bulb in the flat to the energy efficient kind and set us up with Good Energy. I will have to report back whether it turns out I can be ethical AND cut my electricity costs by combining a more expensive green supplier with energy budgeting tactics. I won’t know until I get a bill a couple months down the road.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: